Historical dossiers
Research dossier
Editorial evidence is separate from accepted ancestry. Original records and prior revisions are retained.
Pincher is the J. P. Colby dog described as reared near Newburyport, from Jack White’s Teddy and Colby’s Pansy. Joseph L. Colby’s 1936 caption dates him to December 1896; the header retains year precision rather than treating a catalogue’s 31 December as established. That earlier account distinguishes 72 lb chain weight from 56 lb conditioned weight, while later sources give different habitual-weight labels. The 1936 chapter names Bunch, Twister and Malachy among his offspring; the conflicting Paddy/Pansy branch and the cyclic Pilot version remain separately explained. Stratton recalled seeing Pincher’s original photograph during a visit to Louis Colby. Louis Colby recalls that a man surnamed Parker raised Pincher on a small farm near Newburyport, while J.P. Colby visited about every six months. The reminiscence names a caretaker, not a documented transfer of ownership. The published registration list names Plunger (AKC 107849), born 2 April 1906, from Pincher and Bess, and Spry (AKC 139152), born 1 December 1907, from Pincher and Fanny. The red-and-white description belongs to Spry, not Pincher.
-
Birth
Source-reportedThe cited pedigree entries and the Colby family history report 31 December 1896. No contemporary birth or registration certificate has been inspected.
Source · pincher-pdb -
Historical association
Source-reportedSources attribute breeding and historical ownership to J.P.Colby. The family account places his rearing near Newburyport; the GameDogs entry reports the USA as country of birth and standing. An exact birthplace and dated transfers are not established.
Source · colby-book -
Coat and markings
Source-reportedThe family history describes white with dark patches. FIAPBT describes white with brindle markings; GameDogs says black and white. These descriptions are retained as reports, not a newly verified colour attribute.
Source · pincher-fiapbt -
Reported measurements
DisputedThe family text reports usual weight 75 lb (about 34 kg), while its photograph caption gives 72 lb (about 33 kg). It separately reports a historical conditioned weight 56 lb (about 25 kg). FIAPBT labels 56 lb as chain weight. These measurements and labels disagree; no single precise weight is adopted.
Source · colby-book -
Parentage versions
DisputedSources name Jack White’s Teddy and Colby’s Pansy as parents. The family chart and Pedigree Database name Charlie Lloyd’s Pansy as Mitchell’s Paddy’s dam, while GameDogs names Charlie Lloyd’s Paddy. The two names are not silently merged or resolved.
Source · gamedogs -
Ancestry research boundary
DisputedThe inspected GameDogs Pilot→Darby’s Kit branch returns to Pincher and creates a cycle. It is withheld from genealogical imports. The family prose calls Pilot a grandsire, while its chart places him one generation farther back. Reported pedigrees remain incomplete and outside accepted calculations.
Source · gamedogs -
Descendant references
Source-reportedThe family history names Colby’s Bunch as offspring and distinguishes two dogs named Colby’s Twister. These are source reports, not accepted descendant links. The Colby catalog association is not proof that every Colby-labelled dog descends from Pincher.
Source · colby-book -
Earlier account: December, without a day
Source-reportedThe 1936 caption reports December 1896 without a day; later catalogues encode 31 December. The header retains year precision. Its prose distinguishes 72 lb chain weight (about 33 kg) from 56 lb pit weight (about 25 kg); older conflicting reports remain visible.
Source · colby-1936-pincher -
Named offspring in the 1936 account
Source-reportedJoseph L. Colby’s 1936 Pincher chapter names Colby’s Malachy, Bunch and Twister as offspring. These are historical name reports; no new dog records or parentage edges are created, and the separate Twister identities are not resolved by this mention.
Source · colby-1936-pincher
Bibliography
Bibliography
-
Colby’s Pincher — public pedigree record 1375732
Pedigree Database · Catalog record · Accessed
Public secondary pedigree entry. Contributor identity, original registration documents and independence from other public entries are not established. No surrounding multigeneration dataset or photograph is reused.
-
Colby’s Pincher — FIAPBT record 5650
FIAPBT Pedigree / Villa Liberty · Catalog record · Accessed
Public secondary pedigree entry attributed to Villa Liberty. Registration number is unavailable. Original identity, birth and ownership documents were not inspected. Photograph attribution is not permission to reuse an image.
-
Louis Colby / Diane Jessup — Colby’s Book of the American Pit Bull Terrier (1997), Pincher / Foundation Pedigrees
Source · [3], [8], [9]
-
Louis Colby / Diane Jessup — Colby’s Book of the American Pit Bull Terrier (1997), Pincher / Foundation Pedigrees
· Secondary history · Accessed
Family history, T.F.H. Publications, 1997; Pincher and Paddy sections and Foundation Pedigrees chart (printed p.36). OCR is imperfect; prose calls Pilot a grandsire although the chart places him one generation farther back. Text reports75lb; photograph caption reports72lb. Not a contemporary registration certificate; independence of later database transcriptions is unestablished.
-
Louis B. Colby / Diane Jessup — Colby’s Book of the American Pit Bull Terrier (1997), Pilot import, Pincher upbringing and Tige–Lightner recollections
Louis B. Colby; Diane Jessup · T.F.H. Publications · Secondary history · · Accessed
Public OCR of the same 1997 book already cited elsewhere, not a new independent publication. Reviewed sections: Charlie Lloyd’s Pilot, Colby’s Tige and Colby’s Pincher, printed pages26–29. Page images, contemporary import and ownership documents were not independently inspected. Holden’s Walsall context does not resolve the retained Ireland/United Kingdom birthplace conflict. Parker is a reported caretaker, not a newly asserted owner. Topsey and Neitz are contextual names only; no new identities, accepted ancestry, dates or media have been imported.
-
Louis Colby / Diane Jessup — Colby’s Book of the American Pit Bull Terrier (1997), partial early AKC registration list
Louis Colby / Diane Jessup · T.F.H. Publications · Secondary history · · Accessed
Actual public OCR of the family book, section headed A Partial List of Some Pit Bull Terriers Registered by the American Kennel Club Around the Turn of the Century. Names and identifiers62380,62381,107570,136015,107849,139152,206995 reviewed in their explicit sire/dam contexts. Original AKC certificates and page images not inspected; OCR/transcription may contain errors. Same1997publication as earlier citations, not independent corroboration or PITVU verification. Offspring dates/colour are not subject birth/coat; similarly named Paddys remain distinct. No new identities, accepted or reported edges, registry IDs or images imported.
-
-
GameDogs — Jack White's Teddy, record63666
· Catalog record · Accessed
Secondary user-contributed reference. Original documents and independence from the other references are unestablished; agreement is not documentary verification.
-
GameDogs — Colby’s Pincher, record63663
GameDogs pedigree database · Catalog record · Accessed
Exact subject entry explicitly labels Country of Birth USA. This new citation corrects an inherited reference to ancestral Teddy63666; the older source snapshot and all genealogy claims remain intact. Contributor-supplied reference, not a contemporary certificate or independent verification. Source date31December1896 remains conservatively displayed as1896; no source fighting titles or COI are adopted.
-
Joseph L. Colby, The American Pit Bull Terrier (1936), scan pages34–35
Joseph L. Colby · The News Publishing Co., Sacramento, California · Secondary history · · Accessed
Family-authored retrospective account, scanPDF page34 caption and page35 Pincher chapter, read from original public scan and OCR. Names Jack White of Salem as Teddy owner; describes activity around Boston in1890s and Pansy as female ownedJohnPColby. Pincher caption reportsDecember 1896 with no day, prose72lbchain/56lbpit. Context matches exact Teddy/Pansy/Pincher identities. One publication with three scoped citations, not independent confirmations. Copyright1936 notice; no image reuse grant or free licence established. No canonical birth, accepted ancestry or contemporary ownership proof. PDF SHA2564cd0efdcb3715b2ee2662bfcc1d75e852c33eed2d5d4be82ab11724049343aa7.
-
Early Influences
Richard F. Stratton · Stratton Pitbull · Secondary history · · Accessed
First-person recollection, not independent confirmation.